Criticise and argue without reading the book
February 12, 2020
Someone sent me a private message and insisted on asking me point by point after I sent him part of my book, The Difference Between a Messenger and a Prophet.
This is part of the text of the dialogue that took place between us after that.
He: You said that our master Muhammad is not the seal of the messengers. What is your evidence?
Me: Yes, not the Seal of the Messengers
He: The guide
Me: I want to know the evidence
I will ask you a question and do not evade the answer
He: Go ahead
Me: Is the Angel of Death a messenger from God to take people's souls or not?
yes or no?
Don't evade
He: The Angel of Death is a special job and has nothing to do with the prophets and messengers.
Me: Yes or no?
He is: The Angel of Death is an angel from God. We have nothing to do with him or with him.
Me: You're evading the answer.
Yes, no, or don't you know?
He: Oh, respected intellectual, the Messenger is the one who brings a message of guidance from God.
Me: You didn't answer, my love.
He is: The Angel of Death, whose job is to take souls.
Me: Does he take people's souls as he pleases, or does God command him?
He: Tell me what does Messenger mean?
Me: My love, you didn't answer me
He: Is the death of humans a message?
Me: Yes, no, or don't you know?
He: You are a Sufi
Me, no
Him: My love, you are the one who is running away
Me: Okay, when you answer my question that we agreed you would answer, you will say to me, “My love,” so it is not appropriate for me to continue the conversation with you. You want me to answer you without you answering me.
He: Reply, you cultured person
Unfortunately, you memorize and do not understand.
This is part of a dialogue with someone who is too arrogant to accept the truth in private, and who at the end of the dialogue just mocked me and made me out to be the one who memorized it and did not understand it.
Where did he memorize it from? Okay, from which book did he memorize it if he is one of the people who say that I contradict the consensus of scholars and that I invented an invention that no one had ever done before me??!!!
(Whoever hears the truth and then denies it after knowing it, is one of those who are arrogant towards God, and whoever supports error is from the party of Satan.) Ibn Battah Al-Akbari, may God have mercy on him.
This is part of the text of the dialogue that took place between us after that.
He: You said that our master Muhammad is not the seal of the messengers. What is your evidence?
Me: Yes, not the Seal of the Messengers
He: The guide
Me: I want to know the evidence
I will ask you a question and do not evade the answer
He: Go ahead
Me: Is the Angel of Death a messenger from God to take people's souls or not?
yes or no?
Don't evade
He: The Angel of Death is a special job and has nothing to do with the prophets and messengers.
Me: Yes or no?
He is: The Angel of Death is an angel from God. We have nothing to do with him or with him.
Me: You're evading the answer.
Yes, no, or don't you know?
He: Oh, respected intellectual, the Messenger is the one who brings a message of guidance from God.
Me: You didn't answer, my love.
He is: The Angel of Death, whose job is to take souls.
Me: Does he take people's souls as he pleases, or does God command him?
He: Tell me what does Messenger mean?
Me: My love, you didn't answer me
He: Is the death of humans a message?
Me: Yes, no, or don't you know?
He: You are a Sufi
Me, no
Him: My love, you are the one who is running away
Me: Okay, when you answer my question that we agreed you would answer, you will say to me, “My love,” so it is not appropriate for me to continue the conversation with you. You want me to answer you without you answering me.
He: Reply, you cultured person
Unfortunately, you memorize and do not understand.
This is part of a dialogue with someone who is too arrogant to accept the truth in private, and who at the end of the dialogue just mocked me and made me out to be the one who memorized it and did not understand it.
Where did he memorize it from? Okay, from which book did he memorize it if he is one of the people who say that I contradict the consensus of scholars and that I invented an invention that no one had ever done before me??!!!
(Whoever hears the truth and then denies it after knowing it, is one of those who are arrogant towards God, and whoever supports error is from the party of Satan.) Ibn Battah Al-Akbari, may God have mercy on him.
EN 
AR 
FR 
ES 
PT 
DE 
IT 
PL 
SV 
NB 
FI 
NL 
DA 
CS 
SK 
ET 
LV 
LT 
RU 
BE 
UK 
HU 
BG 
RO 
SR 
HR 
BS 
SQ 
EL 
TR 
HE 
ZH 
JA 
KO 
ID 
MS 
VI 
TL 
TH 
MY 
KM 
HI 
UR 
BN 
FA 
PS 
KK 
UZ 
HY 
KA 
TA 
NE 
SI 
SW 
AM